Case Nº 142Medium
resets --:--:--
Scene of the crime

The Pearls That Stayed Warm

Lamplight glowed down the long gallery of Elderwick Hall. Rain whispered on the tall windows, and the smell of beeswax polish hung in the air. In the center of the gallery stood the glass case that had held the Moonrise Pearls for forty years. Miss Prudence Vale, the appraiser from the city, unlocked the case with Lady Honoria's key, lifted the strand, and touched one bead gently to her cheek. Then she set it down. 'Real pearls feel cool,' she said quietly. 'These stayed warm. These are glass.' Lady Honoria Dunmore went very still. The famous pearls — her grandmother's — were gone, and a careful copy lay in their place. The case lock was unmarked. The key cabinet in the butler's pantry was untouched. Nothing was broken, nothing forced. Somewhere, at some time, the real pearls had simply walked away, and a twin had taken their seat. Four people at Elderwick that night knew the pearls, the case, and the keys well enough to matter. One of them knew far more than that.

Mr. Edwin Carrow
The estate steward for twenty years. He keeps the accounts in a neat round hand and arranges everything at Elderwick — deliveries, repairs, and the pearls' yearly cleaning in the city.
Captain Rufus Hale
Lady Honoria's cheerful nephew, home from sea. He loves card games and loudly jokes that his debts will be the end of him, though nobody has ever seen him pay more than sixpence.
Mrs. Dora Pentle
The housekeeper, brisk and devoted, with keys to nearly every door in the hall. She dusts the gallery case herself each morning and calls the pearls 'my ladies.'
Miss Prudence Vale
The city appraiser, precise and polite, hired to value the pearls for the insurance papers. She arrived at Elderwick only two days ago, with her loupe, her scales, and her notebooks.
Evidence · flip carefully
solve now → 5 pts
    One accusation only — choose with care